Category Archives: Game Design

Talent vs. Effort

This comment came in recently on the article In Defense of D&D Stats in Simple Language: The Definition of Charisma: I think the use of the word “empathy” was the one mistake in your article. Psychopaths by definition don’t have … Continue reading

Posted in DMing, Game Design | Tagged | Comments Off on Talent vs. Effort

The Splash Damage of Alignment Restrictions

I’ve been trying to come up with something else nice to say about 5E. I don’t think it’s a bad system, I just think it took away a lot of the things I like about running D&D games like agency … Continue reading

Posted in Game Design, Gaming Systems | Tagged | 2 Comments

On D&D as a Brand

As I’ve mentioned before, I follow professional wrestling, and today I want to talk Sunday’s WWE event, “Hell in a Cell”. Its namesake is the Hell in a Cell match, which is the big brother of a steel cage match. … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary, DMing, Game Design, Gaming Systems | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

On Pathfinder

I told you that story to tell you this one: I’m starting to wonder if I’m done with Pathfinder. The more I read about Pathfinder and the more I understand the designers’ intentions and the way players use it, the … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary, DMing, Game Design | Tagged | 4 Comments

Strategic Healing and the Vigilante Campaign

In the hubbub around themes, I nearly forgot that I promised to update my opinion on the vigilante once our all-vigilante campaign ended. It turns out I was only 80% correct on the class, in that every problem was about … Continue reading

Posted in Campaigns, DMing, Game Design, House Rules | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Strategic Healing and the Vigilante Campaign

Abilities without Limitations (or, the Rule that Proves the Exception)

There’s a phrase I love explaining to people, because I’ve only met about two or three people who understand it: “the exception that proves the rule”. Most folks think it means “the thing that does not fit a rule proves … Continue reading

Posted in Game Design | Tagged , | Comments Off on Abilities without Limitations (or, the Rule that Proves the Exception)

On the Vigilante

I’ve been spending some time on the Paizo subreddit since one of my players told me I was on it and, in doing so, that it existed. For the most part it’s very similar to the Wizards boards I frequented … Continue reading

Posted in Game Design | Tagged | Comments Off on On the Vigilante

On Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, Part 3: a Game of Choice

I’ve spent two posts going over Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, which gave me a lot of time to shout about what I like and don’t like about it. But I also had time to think about why I feel the … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary, Game Design | Tagged | Comments Off on On Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, Part 3: a Game of Choice

On Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, Part 2: a Class of Ribbons

I think I could really get into reading articles like Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures regularly. The article itself is short, the linked content is interesting, and it gives me some insight into the minds of the developers. If articles in … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary, Game Design | Tagged | Comments Off on On Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, Part 2: a Class of Ribbons

On Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, Part 1: a System of Hats

One of the complaints I have about 5E is that it has so few options, and that’s a complaint I expected to have. I have the same issue whenever I pick up any Core D&D book because it can only … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary, Game Design | Tagged | Comments Off on On Unearthed Arcana: Waterborne Adventures, Part 1: a System of Hats